I Play Rocky is playing in theaters at the time of review. Rated PG-13. Common Sense says 13+
STORY: B-
A crowd-pleasing story that gets stronger as it goes along.
PEOPLE: A
Ippolito shines as Stallone, but the brightest lights come from the supporting cast’s delightful performances.
CRAFT: C-
Bushels of unhidden Easter eggs cover up the capable, but unimaginative, filmmaking.
THEME: B-
You can’t win big if you don’t bet on yourself.
FINAL COMMENTS:
The first half of the film is uneven. It lacks drama. We know the movie gets greenlit. We know Stallone gets the part. Stallone repeats the film’s title ad nauseum, and the effect on the audience isn’t an amplified impact once the studio execs cave. There’s only a sigh of relief.
Yet two elements carry us happily through this repetitive first half. The first is Appolito’s mesmerizing, extraordinary rendering of Sylvester Stallone. The second is the slew of Rocky references. Fans will have a ball watching Stallone drink eggs, pull on gray sweatpants, and pet the O.G. Butkus.
The movie really starts to soar once the question shifts from “Will the movie get made?” to “How does it get made?” Studio honchos, directors, fight choreographers, and co-stars invade the film set, bringing a tender, vibrant energy to the narrative.
There’s also a transcendent moment as Stallone shoots an emotional scene from Rocky. In this moment, the young, largely unknown talent (Stallone) finally finds his footing. It’s framed as the literal moment Stallone transformed from an actor into an ACTOR. We may look back at this moment in I Play Rocky fifty years from now and say the same thing about Ippolito.
This movie is tailor-made for Rocky fans, but it’s also got enough pluck, underdog moments, and Hollywood hijinks to reach a broader audience.
Like the film it chronicles, I Play Rocky is a flat-out crowd pleaser.

